This non-alcoholic party punch tastes just like spiced cider, but refreshing and a little fizzy plus an unexpected (but incredible!) creamy note from vanilla ice cream. Feel free to leave as is for a mocktail party situation or you can spike it with rum for the adults in the room. Perfect for Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas!
Yield: 24
Ingredients
For the punch
1gallonapple cider16 cups/128 ounces, chilled
1large fresh orange peel4-5 inches long; use a vegetable peeler on a fresh orange
10whole cloves
4cinnamon sticks
1cupfresh orange juice8 ounces / fresh squeezed from 4-5 juicy oranges or any store-bought OJ will do
2pintsvanilla ice cream
1litreginger ale4 cups/32 ounces, chilled
For garnish
cinnamon sticks
fresh apple slices
fresh orange slices
Instructions
Add 2 cups of the apple cider to a small saucepan over medium heat. Add the orange peel, cloves, and 4 cinnamon sticks. Bring just to a simmer, then put the lid on the pan and remove from heat. Let sit for 25-30 minuets, until room temp and the spice flavors have infused into the cider.
At this point I like to pull out my ice cream from the freezer to give it some time to soften up.
Pour the remainder of the cider into your punch bowl. Strain the spiced cider from the saucepan into the punch bowl next. Stir in the orange juice.
Add the vanilla ice cream in scoops.
Pour ginger ale over the top.
Ladle individual servings into punch glasses. Garnish with apple slices, orange slices, and/or cinnamon sticks if desired.