Easiest Halloween Witch Finger Breadsticks

Looking for some Halloween finger food ideas? You’ve come to the right place. Like, REALLY the right place.

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches' fingers breadsticks - use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. #halloweenfood #severedfingers #witchesfingersbreadsticks

Come hither, my pretties. That’s right… just a little bit closer.

These numbers – or shall I say, digits – beckon everyone to bite the hand that feeds them. Well, at least the fingers.

Possibly the creepiest breadsticks ever, these Halloween witches’ finger breadsticks are great for dipping in soup or chili, or scooping up some marinara or pizza sauce (ooh, bloody looking! Perfect!)

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches' fingers breadsticks - use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. #halloweenfood #severedfingers #witchesfingersbreadsticks
I wish I could say I pinpointed this idea all by myself, but I actually borrowed it from this Cheddar Witch’s Fingers recipe from Sunset. While I’m all for homemade cheese crackers like in the Sunset version, (my mom makes the most amazing cheese crackers, that reminds me – I really need to get her recipe), I’m a little short on time lately, so I decided to do this the easier way.

Enter: Refrigerator section breadstick dough!

With a tube of breadstick dough and a pack of sliced almonds or some bell peppers, I can whip up some creepy severed witches’ fingers breadsticks in just about as many minutes as I can count on both hands.

Too bad there are a few witches out in the world who won’t be able to say the same anymore… mua ha ha ha ha!

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches' fingers breadsticks - use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. #halloweenfood #severedfingers #witchesfingersbreadsticks

I like to make these two ways. I either use sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail …

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches' fingers breadsticks - use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. #halloweenfood #severedfingers #witchesfingersbreadsticks

Or, after they’ve baked, I dollop with a bit of cream cheese and a long triangle of bell pepper.

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches' fingers breadsticks - use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. #halloweenfood #severedfingers #witchesfingersbreadsticks

I like both types for different reasons. The almonds are a bit easier – just stick them on before baking. But if you’re making these for, say, your kiddo’s classroom, you might need to go the nut-free route. If that’s the case, may I point you to the bell-pepper-and-cream-cheese option.

Or make a few of both and mix ’em all together. No one witches’ finger is unique, after all!

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches' fingers breadsticks - use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. #halloweenfood #severedfingers #witchesfingersbreadsticks

I love to make these with my daughter, not only because they’re loads of fun, but because the more rustic and gnarled up they are, the better. Meticulous perfection is NOT the name of the game here, and she likes to get a little crazy.

My kiddo loves to help with everything from cutting the breadsticks to adding the fingernail to brushing with egg wash (an optional step, but it adds a bit of shininess. Surely witches fingers are a bit shiny from all that time above a steamy cauldron, right?)

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches' fingers breadsticks - use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. #halloweenfood #severedfingers #witchesfingersbreadsticks

However you choose to make witches’ finger breadsticks, just go forth and make some. Then step back, look at your Halloween accomplishment, and give yourself a HAND!

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches' fingers breadsticks - use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. #halloweenfood #severedfingers #witchesfingersbreadsticks

Did you make this recipe?   Leave a review »

Halloween Witches' Fingers Breadsticks

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches’ fingers breadsticks – use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. Mani-pedi, anyone?

Ingredients:

  • One roll of refrigerated soft breadsticks dough (I usually buy Pillsbury soft breadsticks)
  • 1 large egg, beaten (optional)
  • Marinara sauce or pizza sauce for serving/dipping (optional)

For the fingernails:

  • Sliced almonds
    OR
  • Red and green bell peppers, cut into narrow 1-inch triangles -and-
  • About 1/4 cup cream cheese or vegan cream cheese

Directions:

  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, or, if the temperature on your package of refrigerated breadstick dough indicates a different temperature, follow the temperature on the package. Line a large baking sheet with parchment paper or a Silpat.
  2. Unroll the breadsticks onto a large cutting board (or your counter or wherever you like to do doughy things).
  3. Using a pizza cutter, slice each breadstick in half vertically and again horizontally. Each breadstick should be about 3-4 inches long and 1/2-inch to 1 inch wide, but perfection is highly discouraged! The more rustic the more realistic. 🙂
  4. Roll the dough a bit to round it a bit/give it more of a finger shape. Lay it on the baking sheet.
  5. Using your thumb, press down on the narrowest tip of each breadstick. If using almonds, press a sliced almond onto each tip. If using bell peppers, you’ll add them AFTER the breadsticks have baked.
  6. Now, you have a couple of options. You can grab the pizza cutter or a bread knife and press a three or four horizontal lines into the middle of the breadstick so it’ll look a bit like a knuckle. And/or, if desired, brush lightly with egg. This will give them a slightly shinier and more golden appearance. Or skip those steps and just stick ’em in the oven already!
  7. Bake for 10-12 minutes, until puffy and starting to brown on the top. But again, if the label on your breadsticks indicates a different time, I recommend going by that time and just checking them often.
  8. Let cool for about 5 minutes on the baking sheet, then transfer to a wire rack to cool completely.
  9. If adding bell pepper for the fingernails, after they’ve cooled, dab the tip with a bit of cream cheese and stick the bell pepper on. You may want to dry the pepper off with a paper towel so it will adhere better.
  10. Arrange on a plate or in mini mason jars filled with marinara or pizza sauce. Bloooody!
  11. Almond-tipped fingers keep in an airtight container at room temperature for several days. Because of the cream cheese and cut pepper, I recommend storing that version in the refrigerator.
All images and text © for Kitchen Treaty.

Originally published Oct 22, 2009. Updated October 20, 2017.

Witch finger will you eat first? Here are two ways to make delightfully creepy witches' fingers breadsticks - use either sliced almonds for the gnarly fingernail or go for bell pepper for a nut-free version. #halloweenfood #severedfingers #witchesfingersbreadsticks

Kare

Kare is a vegetarian home cook living among carnivores. She loves creating irresistible and flexible recipes that help multi-vore families like hers keep the peace - deliciously.